home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=94TT0386>
- <title>
- Apr. 11, 1994: Still Punishing the Victims
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1994
- Apr. 11, 1994 Risky Business on Wall Street
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- HAITI, Page 55
- Still Punishing the Victims
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p>A wavering U.S. policy has wrought little except greater disparity
- between Haiti's rich and poor
- </p>
- <p>By Cathy Booth/Ouanaminthe--With reporting by Ana Martinez/Santo Domingo and J.F.O. McAllister/Washington
- </p>
- <p> Like an army of ants, Haitians by the hundreds scurry up and
- down the dusty banks of the Massacre River with their gallon
- plastic jugs. Their day's work done, they head home carrying
- vessels filled with a precious pink fluid: gasoline smuggled
- across the river from the Dominican Republic. For the people
- of Ouanaminthe in northeastern Haiti, the daily trek has become
- an economic necessity since last October, when the United Nations
- reimposed a fuel embargo against the country's recalcitrant
- military rulers.
- </p>
- <p> The embargo is nearly six months old, and the military is still
- in power--awash in gasoline and profits, thanks to the porous
- border with the Dominican Republic. The reality of oil-embargoed
- Haiti is nowhere more evident than in the capital of Port-au-Prince,
- which suffers from traffic jams. Though the brightly colored
- "tap tap" jitneys used by the poor are disappearing as gas prices
- soar, the military and the monied still manage to race around
- town in their Range Rovers and Toyotas tanked up on $150 of
- smuggled fuel. "The embargo exists in name only. They sell gasoline
- like chocolate bars on the streets," says an angry Senator Christopher
- Dodd, just back from a trip to the island.
- </p>
- <p> Trade and travel sanctions imposed by the U.N. and the Organization
- of American States were designed to punish the military and
- its elite backers for overthrowing President Jean-Bertrand Aristide
- in September 1991. Yet even a modicum of money buys a pleasant
- life-style in Haiti. Ships from Europe keep stores in middle-class
- Petionville stocked with Italian artichoke hearts and Georges
- Duboeuf wine from France. Last December the so-called friends
- of Haiti--the U.S., France, Canada and Venezuela--warned
- the military that they would seek a worldwide U.N. embargo on
- all commercial goods to Haiti unless progress was made to restore
- Aristide to power by Jan. 15. That threat proved hollow, however.
- Desperate to get rid of the Haiti problem without touching off
- a new exodus of refugees, the Clinton Administration has drifted
- from one version of a peace plan to another, apparently moved
- more by shifting public pressures than by events. Late last
- month Vice President Al Gore tried to sell Aristide on a plan
- that would leave Haiti's most powerful man, Port-au-Prince police
- chief Lieut. Colonel Michel Francois, in place without setting
- a date for the President's own return--a retreat from the
- Governors Island accord signed last summer.
- </p>
- <p> It is Haiti's poor, already the poorest in the western hemisphere,
- who bear the brunt of the embargo. Food prices have doubled,
- putting staples like rice, beans and oil beyond the reach of
- many. Relief officials at CARE describe the current situation
- as the worst since the 1950s, with moderate and severe malnutrition
- plaguing some 20% of preschool children. Doctors report a rise
- in tuberculosis cases and an epidemic of anthrax. "The embargo
- must be lifted," says Christiana Dormestoin, who scrounges food
- for her four children. "We're poor people. We only want to feed
- our children. We don't care about politics."
- </p>
- <p> The military, meanwhile, has allowed right-wing paramilitary
- groups to wage a campaign of terror in pro-Aristide neighborhoods.
- In the capital's Cite Soleil slum, dead bodies are left in the
- streets daily, sometimes with their faces peeled off and limbs
- missing. Over the past two months, observers with the U.N.-
- OAS civilian mission report 106 killings, 35 disappearances
- and dozens of rapes involving women under 20. Much of the violence
- is blamed on FRAPH, or the Front for the Advancement and Progress
- of Haiti, the modern-day successors to the feared Tontons Macoutes.
- "The level of repression and violence is rising daily, and the
- police just seem to stand by and tolerate it," says Colin Ganderson,
- the mission's director.
- </p>
- <p> The military has used the embargo to become richer and more
- powerful: it now controls state monopolies like electric service,
- phones and port facilities. "The military has probably got hernias
- laughing at the embargo," says an irate relief official. Despite
- the U.N. naval blockade, U.S. sources estimate as much as a
- third of the pre-embargo gasoline supply is flowing in by land
- and sea from the Dominican Republic. So much gasoline comes
- across the Massacre River on the northern border that locals
- jokingly refer to the area as "Kuwait." For a bribe, Dominican
- soldiers turn a blind eye to traffickers.
- </p>
- <p> Human-rights observers charge the U.N. is being hypocritical
- by posting ships around Haiti, then not enforcing the border
- crossings. "The United Nations knows the border is like a sieve,
- and yet it's allowed the Dominican Republic to violate the embargo,
- keeping the military alive," said a human-rights observer. In
- one day last month observers counted 40 trucks piled high with
- drums containing an estimated 66,000 gal. of gas leaving the
- border at Ouanaminthe. Last week the "four friends" agreed to
- push for U.N. monitors along the 240-mile border, and Jaoquin
- Balaguer, the aging President of the Dominican Republic, promised
- Dodd to shut the border "in due course."
- </p>
- <p> Haiti's assembly industry, given special license to export clothes
- to the U.S. despite the embargo, is suffering from the collapse
- of the electric system. Its work force has shrunk from 60,000
- to fewer than 8,000. "The embargo is a poison that's killing
- us all, first the innocent and now factory owners like myself,"
- says clothing-factory owner Georges Barau Sassine. Public services
- have all but
- disappeared. With garbage collection halted, the U.S. pays to
- clean the streets of Port-au-Prince at a cost of $2 million
- annually to American taxpayers.
- </p>
- <p> Embargo supporters argue that Haiti's deterioration will eventually
- undermine the army. But as the embargo drags on, Haitians both
- rich and poor feel increasingly abandoned. There is talk in
- Washington and Port-au-Prince of letting the crisis--and the
- embargo--run its course until Aristide's five-year term expires
- in early 1996. In the office of one businesswoman hangs a calendar
- that symbolizes Haiti's despair: each day is marked off with
- a giant X--to keep track of the time remaining in Aristide's
- presidential term. At last glance it was 666 days and counting.
- </p>
-
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-